Why Your Nonprofit Needs a Clear Succession Plan

Nobody wants to think about what happens when key leadership leaves.  It's uncomfortable and feels a little morbid. It's the organizational equivalent of having a will or not — something you know you should do and keep pushing to "someday." 

But here's the thing: someday will eventually come. And being prepared now could prevent a crisis. 

What Is a Succession Plan, and Why Does It Matter? 

A nonprofit succession plan is a documented strategy for what happens when a key leader (most critically, your Executive Director and Board Chair) transitions out of their role. Whether that's a planned retirement, a sudden resignation, a health emergency, or just someone finally taking that dream job in Bali, you need a plan. 

Without one, you're not just scrambling to fill a seat. You're risking donor confidence, stalling programs, confusing staff, and threatening the very mission you've worked so hard to build. Strong nonprofit leadership succession planning is what separates organizations that grow stronger through transitions from those that crumble. 

Your Executive Director: The Hardest Seat to Fill 

Let's be honest, when your Executive Director leaves, it can feel like the whole organization is holding its breath. The ED is often the face of the organization, the relationship-holder with funders, and the person who knows where everything can be found. 

A succession plan for this role should include a clear internal leadership pipeline. Who on your team is being developed for greater responsibility? What would an interim look like? What knowledge needs to be passed down? 

You don't have to have a name ready. You have to have a process ready. 

Your Board Chair: The Role That Sneaks Up on You 

Board Chair succession gets far less attention than it deserves. This role is just as critical to have a succession plan for. The Board Chair is responsible for the strategic direction of your organization and naturally has more frequent turnover than staff. 

Your board should be actively cultivating its next Chair before the current one steps down. That means identifying emerging board leaders, giving them meaningful committee experience, and making leadership development part of your board culture. This shouldn’t be a last-minute scramble. 

When to Start (Hint: Right Now) 

The best time to create your succession plan was when your organization first formed. The second best time is today. This isn't a document you pull out only when someone announces they're leaving. It's a living plan, revisited annually, that keeps your organization resilient no matter what.  

Want monthly strategies for creating a sustainable organization? Subscribe to my newsletter!